Software-Defined Security Services Working Group–March 16, 2017 Meeting Notes

by LINDA DUNBAR, Huawei

Time: March 16, 2017: 11am EST – 12pm EST.

Participants: Ali Sydney; Chris Messina; Hari K, Linda Dunbar; Mukesh Gupta; Nick; Rakesh Kumar; Scott Brander; Simon Fiddian; Scrini; Thom S; Call-in_user 1;

Use Case and White paper discussion

Rakesh:

  • Good discussion on the use case on the mailing list.
  • Security white paper: need more clarity on use cases
  • Need richer policy

Nick:

  • What we do in ONUG takes one step closer to the implementation.
  • Let’s put the document on the wiki page for more people to view.

 Mukesh:

  • It has been difficult to put everything. Need more comments.

Nick:

  • Other groups also have framework document. We might need to blow up the pictures for the Spring Work
  • Use the use cases as guidance for any company to showcase their proof of concept. Issue award to companies that have the best matches with the framework, to amplify the work done by ONUG.

Scott: it might be difficult to organize it.

Rakesh:

  • We can create multiple pictures, one is consolidated one, others are “individual ones”

Linda:

  • can we separate Infrastructure security polices from polices impose on user data.

Mukesh:

  • It is important to have policies on which users can access which port

User_2: we should identify the trust boundary. For trusted domain, you don’t need security policies for access control. For untrusted domain, you need more policies.

Nick: it probably too early for the award process. The purpose is to create more interests for this framework.

Scrini: has the data models been published anywhere?

Rakesh: the data models are specified at IETF I2NSF. There is north bound data models.

Linda: we should brief the data models being proposed by IETF I2NSF WG and get more feedback from ONUG Wg. If agreed, we can attach one page of data models to the Framework post at the ONUG Spring.

Nick: it is more important to have a small set of use cases, instead of a lot of them.  For example: for data center, the key use cases are segregation. Should focus on a few important one

Tom: should focus on one key use case: how to run work load securely in an environment owned by 3rd party. If you can solve this problem: confidentiality, integrity, availability. Untrusted service providers who are running my applications, the VMs run there have no idea. How do I mitigate that threat? How to use commodity resource that are not trusted. Can we develop a solutions around it?

Srini: there are other use cases as well, IoT connecting to the network, not sure if this group is only for WorkLoad security?

Nick: everyone is so focused on Hybrid cloud, being able to move work load from trusted environment to untrusted environment is key. IoT is interesting, but enterprises are not knocking our door for this.

If we can focus on what Nick has suggested, we are doing a good service to the community.

Monitoring and Analytics

Notice: The views and opinions expressed here are collective derived from the members of this ONUG Working Group and are not the express opinion of any individual or companies. 

SPRING 2018

ONUG Spring 2018–May 8 & 9 @ UCSF, San Francisco, hosted by Kaiser Permanente 

M&A Working Group Chairs:

Aryo Kresnadi, FedEx
Ted Turner, Intuit
Paul Barrett, NetScout
Richard Whitehead, Moogsoft

Secretary:

 

Spring 2018 Meeting Schedule (via WebEx):

Every other Tuesday @ 12:00 pm ET starting January 23, 2018

Spring 2018 ONUG Workshops:

March 6 & 7, 2018, Sunnyvale, CA

September 2018, NYC (dates and location tbd)

An Introduction to Monitoring and Analytics Requirements White Paper (April 2017)

Members (Sponsors to be added as they are confirmed):

Stephen Collins ACG Research
Shane Jenkins Adobe Systems
Tavarez Dudley Advocate Insiders
Venkatarao Mokkapati American Express
Yan Filyurin Bloomberg
Leo Pang Bloomberg
Chris Cheu Cigna
Kunal Mahajan Columbia University
Vesko Pehlivanov Credit Suisse
Yong Xue DISA/DoD
Jeff Kopko DTCC
Jamie Jacobs eBay
Luyuan Fang eBay
Mark Kisner Fidelity
Michael Wynston First Data
Regis Rogers General Electric
Snehal Patel Gap
Vishal Goradia Gap
Scott Bradner Independent
Jem Pagan JNK Securities
Russ White LinkedIn
Kosha Jobanputra KPMG
Bruno Dias MaplesFS
Rhett Dillingham Moor Insights & Strategy
Ian Noble Noblevision
Harinder Singh Sainsburys
Niranjan Nandakumar Susquehanna International Group, LLP
Brian Anderson Tegna
Rodger Xu Teranet
Arpit Rana University @ Buffalo
Yufeng Xin UNC at Chapel Hill
Sean Wang University of British Columbia
Victor Liu Visa
Kaya Westling Wells Fargo

 

Abhinav Modi Avi
Jesse Brower cPacket
Vittal Krishnamurthy cPacket
Josh Joiner cPacket
Kerry Takenaka cPacket
Nikhil Handigol Forward
Michael Haugh Gluware
Don Fedyk Hewlett Packard Enterprise
Peter Mellquist Hewlett Packard Enterprise
Ahmad Zamer Hewlett Packard Enterprise
Srihari Venkiteswaran HPE
Linda Dunbar Huawei
Yang Yang Huawei
George Zhao Huawei
Huiyang Yang Huawei
Yan Zhuang Huawei
Wei Wei Huawei
Yizhou Li Huawei
Derek (Houjianqiang)
  Huawei
Margaret Chiosi Huawei
Konstantinos Kanonakis Huawei
Sankar Ramamoorthi Juniper
Michael Langdon Juniper
Anil Lohiya Juniper
Jacopo Pianigiani Juniper
Travis Newhouse Juniper
Eric Graham Kentik
Justin Ryburn Kentik
Richard Whitehead Moogsoft
Babak Roushanaee NetScout
Totti Murakami NetOne Systems
Yusuke Fujita NetOne Systems
Yudai Iwasaki NTTi3
Daisuke Morita NTTi3
Nabil Bitar Nuage
Senad Palislamovic Nuage
Mostafa Mansour Nuage
Jeff Tantsura Nuage
Gopi Gopalakrishnan ThousandEyes
Yefim Pipko ThousandEyes
Sanjay Mehta ThousandEyes
Brighten Godfrey Veriflow
Daniel Johnson Verizon
Bryan Larish Verizon
Cheng Liu Verizon
Dogu Narin Versa

FALL 2017

ONUG FALL 2017 October 17 & 18 in NYC

M&A Initiative Chairs:

Aryo Kresnadi, FedEx
Neal Secher, BNY Mellon
Ted Turner, Intuit
Paul Barrett, NetScout
Nabil Bitar, Nuage

Secretary:

Karlo Zatylny, SolarWinds

Fall 2017 Meeting Schedule (via WebEx):

June 6 @ 12:00 pm ET
June 27 @ 12:00 pm ET
July 18 @ 12:00 pm ET
August 29 @ 12:00 pm ET
September 26 @ 12:00 pm ET

Fall 2017 ONUG Initiatives Workshops:

July 25 & 26 in NYC

Members (Vendors to be added as they are confirmed): 

Stephen Collins ACG Research
Tavarez Dudley Advocate Insiders
Venkatarao Mokkapati American Express
Yan Filyurin Bloomberg
Rosemary Wang BNY Mellon
Vesko Pehlivanov Credit Suisse
Yong Xue DISA/DoD
Jamie Jacobs eBay
Luyuan Fang eBay
Regis Rogers General Electric
Snehal Patel Gap
Mark Kisner Fidelity
Michael Wynston First Data
Scott Bradner Independent
Jem Pagan JNK Securities
Arup Chakravarty MetLife
Ian Noble Noblevision
Niranjan Nandakumar Susquehanna International Group, LLP
Brian Anderson Tegna
Yufeng Xin UNC at Chapel Hill
Victor Liu Visa
Kaya Westling Wells Fargo
Ian Flint Yahoo

SPRING 2017

ONUG SPRING 2017 April 25 & 26 in San Francisco

M&A Initiative Chairs:

Aryo Kresnadi, FedEx
Neal Secher, BNY Mellon
Ted Turner, Intuit
Paul Barrett, NetScout
Nabil Bitar, Nuage

Secretary:

Karlo Zatylny, SolarWinds

Spring 2017 Meeting Schedule (via WebEx):

February 1 @ 12:00 pm ET  CLICK HERE for Meeting Notes
March 1 @ 12:00 pm ET CLICK HERE for Meeting Notes
March 22 @ 12:00 pm ET
April 12 @ 12:00 pm ET

Spring 2017 ONUG Initiatives Workshops:

February 15 @ 11 am-6 pm, NYC  CLICK HERE for Meeting Notes
March 8 @ 11 am-6 pm, CA  CLICK HERE for Meeting Notes
March 28 @ 11 am-6 pm, NYC

Members:

Stephen Collins ACG Research
Tavarez Dudley Advocate Insiders
Venkatarao Mokkapati American Express
Yan Filyurin Bloomberg
Rosemary Wang BNY Mellon
Vesko Pehlivanov Credit Suisse
Yong Xue DISA
Jamie Jacobs eBay
Regis Rogers General Electric
Snehal Patel Gap
Michael Wynston First Data
Scott Bradner Independent
Jem Pagan JNK Securities
Arup Chakravarty MetLife
Niranjan Nandakumar Susquehanna International Group, LLP
Brian Anderson Tegna
Yufeng Xin UNC at Chapel Hill
Victor Liu Visa
Kaya Westling Wells Fargo

 

Manoj Kale Cisco
Manish Kumar Cisco
Aaron Linn Cisco
Nagendra Kumar Nainar Cisco
Tina Zhang Cisco
Dave Ward Cisco
Jesse Brower cPacket Networks
Vittal Krishnamurthy cPacket Networks
Josh Joiner cPacket Networks
Nikhil Handigol Forward Networks
Don Fedyk Hewlett Packard Enterprise
Peter Mellquist Hewlett Packard Enterprise
Ahmad Zamer Hewlett Packard Enterprise
Linda Dunbar Huawei
Yang Yang Huawei
George Zhao Huawei
Huiyang Yang Huawei
Babak Roushanaee NetScout
Paul Barrett NetScout
Kirk O’Connor NetScout
Senad Palislamovic Nuage
Jonathan Cornell Pluribus
Pierre-Louis Gingembre Pluribus
Sunay Tripathi Pluribus
Steven Shalita Pluribus
Lee Calcote SolarWinds
Gopi Gopalakrishnan ThousandEyes
Yefim Pipko ThousandEyes
Sanjay Mehta ThousandEyes
Dogu Narin Versa
Sandeep Bajaj Viptela

Software-Defined Security Services

Notice: The views and opinions expressed here are collective derived from the members of this ONUG Working Group and are not the express opinion of any individual or companies. The white paper has gone through final edits; please do not make any changes.

(more…)